The Other Meals of Thanksgiving Week… Seafood Is the Answer!

Because Thanksgiving isn't just one meal…and nobody wants to cook a feast every day of the week.

By Jennifer Bushman, Executive Director of Fed by Blue 

Thanksgiving, or Friendsgiving or Turkey Day as many celebrate it, is a time to savor and honor food, family, friends, and the simple joy of gathering around a table. 

But somewhere between the grocery shopping, pie baking, turkey brining, and inevitable scramble for oven space, we tend to forget one important detail: People still need to eat the rest of the week! 

And if you're the one hosting and having guests stay with you, you know exactly what I mean.

There's Tuesday dinner, Wednesday's revolving door of arriving guests, Thursday's pre-feast grazing, and the moment on Friday when no one is excited for a turkey sandwich. 

This is where seafood becomes your secret holiday weapon. Quick to prepare, wonderfully versatile, and available in everything from beautiful fresh fillets to smoked seafood and pantry-friendly tins, responsibly sourced blue foods can make Thanksgiving week easier, more delicious, and a whole lot less stressful.

Here's how to make seafood the star of all those other Thanksgiving week meals. 

Tuesday: The Calm Before the Culinary Storm

By Tuesday, the refrigerator is packed, the countertops are buried under ingredients, and every available mixing bowl has been claimed for Thanksgiving prep. The last thing anyone wants is another complicated dinner. Enter fish: one of the fastest proteins you can cook.

A beautiful piece of salmon, trout, or another favorite fish can get from the fridge to the table in just 15 minutes. Pair it with a simple salad, roasted vegetables, or some crusty bread, and dinner is done. One of our favorite tricks is to keep a few fish fillets on hand, along with precooked rice, a jar of curry simmering sauce, and some fresh greens. Warm the sauce in a skillet, gently simmer the fish until cooked through, toss in a handful of spinach, and serve over rice. It's comforting, flavorful, and requires just one pan. Even better? You haven't touched the oven that's working overtime this week. 

Wednesday: The Guests Are Coming! The Guests Are Coming!

You know how it goes. Someone arrives at noon, another at four, and the last flight doesn't land until nearly midnight. Everyone is hungry, but no one needs a formal meal. You want to pour a glass of wine, catch up, and enjoy the people you've been looking forward to seeing. This is the moment to embrace the wonderful world of tinned and smoked seafood. 

Tinned fish has experienced a well-deserved culinary renaissance, and for good reason. Beautifully packed sardines, mussels, trout, salmon, and tuna offer extraordinary flavor with almost no preparation.

Create a simple seafood grazing board with a few favorite tins, smoked fish, good crackers, toasted bread, pickled vegetables, olives, lemon wedges, and a little mustard or aioli. Guests can help themselves whenever they arrive, and you can spend your time visiting instead of hovering over the stove. 

For something a little more substantial, toss high-quality tinned tuna with white beans, olive oil, lemon, fresh herbs, and a handful of arugula. You can even add cooked pasta to this mixture for something more substantial! It's a meal in minutes, with almost no cleanup. And isn't that exactly what Wednesday should be about?

Thursday: The Art of the Pre-Feast Appetizer

Thanksgiving Day is a marathon, not a sprint. The oven is occupied, the stovetop is prime real estate, and everyone seems to wander into the kitchen asking, "When are we eating?” You need appetizers that feel special without filling everyone up before the main event. Seafood is practically made for this moment.  

Think chilled shrimp with a bright cocktail sauce, smoked trout spread with crackers, oysters on the half shell, or delicate bites of cured salmon with cucumber and fresh dill. These are festive, elegant, and wonderfully light.

But if you're looking for something warm, comforting, and memorable, I have another idea! 

One of the recipes I’m excited to share this Thanksgiving is the Dueling Chowders from Barton Seaver and Andrew Zimmern in The Blue Food Cookbook. 

Chowder has a special way of bringing people together. It's warm, welcoming, and deeply connected to America's coastal food traditions. What makes this such a wonderful Thanksgiving option is that much of the preparation can happen ahead of time. 

Make the chowder in advance, refrigerate it safely, and gently reheat it on the stovetop when guests begin to gather. Serve small portions in cups or little bowls rather than full-sized servings. It's just enough to satisfy those pre-dinner appetites without competing with the turkey.

And there's something particularly lovely about offering guests a taste of the sea before sitting down to celebrate the harvest from the land.

Friday and Saturday: When Turkey Fatigue Sets In

Let's be clear: I love Thanksgiving leftovers. But there comes a point usually somewhere between Friday afternoon and Saturday morning when even the most devoted turkey enthusiast is ready for something completely different. Seafood to the rescue again! 

Friday is perfect for a bright, fresh seafood meal that offers a welcome contrast to Thursday's rich dishes. Try fish tacos with crunchy cabbage, lime, and a little spicy crema. Or make a simple seafood pasta with garlic, olive oil, lemon, and shrimp.

By Saturday, when everyone is settling into the holiday weekend, consider a one-pot seafood curry, a comforting bowl of fish (or seaweed!) stew, or a beautiful piece of pan-seared fish served with greens and rice. These meals feel satisfying without being heavy, and they're easy to adapt depending on how many guests are still around. And perhaps best of all, they remind us that holiday cooking doesn't have to mean spending every waking moment in the kitchen.

A Little More Blue on the Thanksgiving Table

At Fed by Blue, we believe that the future of food is deeply connected to the health of our waters. 

Choosing responsibly sourced seafood is one way we can support the fishers, water farmers, and coastal communities working to produce nourishing food while protecting the ecosystems on which we all depend. 

Thanksgiving is a celebration of abundance and gratitude. It's also a wonderful opportunity to think about where our food comes from, the people who produce it, and the choices we make around our tables. And while the turkey may always have its place of honor on Thursday, there's plenty of room for blue foods throughout the rest of the week.

So this year, stock the pantry with a few beautiful tins of seafood. Pick up some smoked fish. Keep a few responsibly sourced fillets ready for a quick dinner. And consider adding a little chowder to your Thanksgiving traditions.

The best holiday meals aren't necessarily the ones that take all day to prepare. They're the ones that give us more time with the people we love.

From all of us at Fed by Blue, Happy Thanksgiving!

Explore more delicious ways to bring responsibly sourced blue foods to your table in The Blue Food Cookbook, by Andrew Zimmern and Barton Seaver.

Next
Next

What If Every Coastal City Had a Seafood Innovation Hub?